{"id":1458,"date":"2005-08-22T15:09:46","date_gmt":"2005-08-22T12:09:46","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/www.mummila.net\/marginaali\/?p=1458"},"modified":"2005-08-22T15:09:46","modified_gmt":"2005-08-22T12:09:46","slug":"hercule-poirot-vastaan-sherlock-holmes-vastaan-mr-spock","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/mummila.net\/marginaali\/2005\/08\/22\/hercule-poirot-vastaan-sherlock-holmes-vastaan-mr-spock\/","title":{"rendered":"Hercule Poirot vastaan Sherlock Holmes vastaan Mr. Spock"},"content":{"rendered":"

Muis\u00adtan, \"Sherlock kuin\u00adka pie\u00adne\u00adn\u00e4 pidin Poi\u00adrot\u2019s\u00adta pal\u00adjon enem\u00adm\u00e4n kuin Hol\u00adme\u00adsis\u00adta. Itse asias\u00adsa minua har\u00admit\u00adti se, etten tyk\u00e4n\u00adnyt Hol\u00admes-sar\u00adjas\u00adta, kos\u00adka tie\u00adsin kui\u00adten\u00adkin, ett\u00e4 Hol\u00adme\u00adsia pidet\u00adtiin yhte\u00adn\u00e4 klas\u00adsik\u00adkoet\u00adsi\u00advis\u00adt\u00e4 (jol\u00adlei per\u00e4\u00adti klas\u00adsi\u00adsim\u00adpa\u00adna) Poi\u00adrot\u2019n ohel\u00adla. #<\/a><\/p>\n

Se, etten tyk\u00e4n\u00adnyt Hol\u00adme\u00adsis\u00adta, joh\u00adtui ennen muu\u00adta sii\u00adt\u00e4, ett\u00e4 koin, ett\u00e4 sar\u00adjas\u00adsa pimi\u00adtet\u00adtiin kat\u00adso\u00adjal\u00adta arvoi\u00adtus\u00adten rat\u00adkai\u00adse\u00admi\u00adsen kan\u00adnal\u00adta kes\u00adkei\u00adsi\u00e4 joh\u00adto\u00adlan\u00adko\u00adja; Hol\u00admes saat\u00adtoi yht\u00e4k\u00adki\u00e4 ker\u00adtoa jos\u00adtain p\u00e4\u00e4\u00adtel\u00adm\u00e4s\u00adt\u00e4\u00e4n ja vas\u00adta sii\u00adn\u00e4 yhtey\u00addes\u00ads\u00e4 pal\u00adjas\u00adtaa, ett\u00e4 oli vaik\u00adka\u00adpa k\u00e4y\u00adnyt vale\u00adpu\u00adkui\u00adse\u00adna jos\u00adsain urk\u00adki\u00admas\u00adsa lis\u00e4\u00adtie\u00adto\u00adja. My\u00f6s Poi\u00adrot saat\u00adtoi ker\u00adtoa havain\u00adneen\u00adsa joh\u00adto\u00adlan\u00adgan, jota ei aiem\u00admin ollut samas\u00adsa pai\u00adkas\u00adsa n\u00e4h\u00adnyt (jol\u00adloin se ker\u00adtoo lavas\u00adtus\u00adyri\u00adtyk\u00adses\u00adt\u00e4), mut\u00adta aina\u00adkin halusin uskoa, ett\u00e4 peri\u00adaat\u00adtees\u00adsa kat\u00adso\u00adjal\u00adla oli my\u00f6s ollut mah\u00addol\u00adli\u00adsuus teh\u00add\u00e4 sama havain\u00adto aiem\u00admin, ja sovel\u00adtaa n\u00e4in samaa \u201cetsi kuvis\u00adta vii\u00adsi eroa\u201d -logiik\u00adkaa. #<\/a><\/p>\n

Ihai\u00adlin kyl\u00adl\u00e4 molem\u00adpia hah\u00admo\u00adja. Kai\u00adken taus\u00adtal\u00adla oli tie\u00adtys\u00adti halu\u00adni kil\u00adpail\u00adla n\u00e4i\u00adt\u00e4 \u00e4lyn ja logii\u00adkan j\u00e4t\u00adti\u00adl\u00e4i\u00adsi\u00adn\u00e4 pidet\u00adty\u00adj\u00e4 mie\u00adhi\u00e4 vas\u00adtaan ja osoit\u00adtaa oma parem\u00admuu\u00adte\u00adni. #<\/a><\/p>\n

Vas\u00adta var\u00adsin \u00e4sket\u00adt\u00e4in, joi\u00adtain vuo\u00adsia sit\u00adten, minul\u00adle val\u00adke\u00adni, ett\u00e4 n\u00e4m\u00e4 hah\u00admot ovat perin poh\u00adjin vial\u00adli\u00adsia. Se tapah\u00adtui, kun olin ollut jon\u00adkin aikaa pait\u00adsios\u00adsa molem\u00admis\u00adta, ja rupe\u00adsin kuun\u00adte\u00adle\u00admaan Chris\u00adtien alku\u00adpe\u00adr\u00e4i\u00adsi\u00e4 Poi\u00adrot-tari\u00adnoi\u00adta kir\u00adjas\u00adton kase\u00adteil\u00adta (olin sil\u00adloin niin uupu\u00adnut, etten jak\u00adsa\u00adnut lukea), mut\u00adtei niin\u00adk\u00e4\u00e4n sen joh\u00addos\u00adta, vaan ylei\u00adsem\u00admin ajat\u00adte\u00adlus\u00adsa\u00adni tapah\u00adtu\u00adnei\u00adden muu\u00adtos\u00adten takia. #<\/a><\/p>\n

Molem\u00admat hah\u00admot vetoa\u00advat tun\u00adne\u00adtus\u00adti \u00e4\u00e4rim\u00adm\u00e4i\u00adsen vah\u00advas\u00adti logiik\u00adkaan ja p\u00e4\u00e4t\u00adte\u00adly\u00adket\u00adju\u00adjen ja j\u00e4r\u00adjen k\u00e4yt\u00adt\u00f6\u00f6n. Ongel\u00adma on sii\u00adn\u00e4, ett\u00e4 sii\u00adn\u00e4 ty\u00f6s\u00ads\u00e4, jota he teke\u00adv\u00e4t, logiik\u00adka ei todel\u00adli\u00adsuu\u00addes\u00adsa toi\u00admi niin kuin tari\u00adnat anta\u00advat ymm\u00e4r\u00adt\u00e4\u00e4. Se edel\u00adlyt\u00adt\u00e4i\u00adsi nimit\u00adt\u00e4in ensin\u00adn\u00e4\u00adkin, ett\u00e4 ihmi\u00adset ovat aja\u00adtuk\u00adsis\u00adsaan v\u00e4hin\u00adt\u00e4\u00e4n\u00adkin yht\u00e4 joh\u00addon\u00admu\u00adkai\u00adsia ja loo\u00adgi\u00adsia kuin etsi\u00adv\u00e4t ty\u00f6s\u00ads\u00e4\u00e4n, ja toi\u00adsek\u00adseen, ett\u00e4 enna\u00adkoi\u00admat\u00adto\u00admien asioi\u00adden osuus tapah\u00adtu\u00admien kulus\u00adsa oli\u00adsi ep\u00e4\u00adluon\u00adnol\u00adli\u00adsen pie\u00adni. #<\/a><\/p>\n

N\u00e4is\u00adt\u00e4 kah\u00addes\u00adta etsi\u00adv\u00e4s\u00adt\u00e4 nime\u00adno\u00admaan Poi\u00adrot on t\u00e4m\u00e4n takia ep\u00e4\u00adus\u00adkot\u00adta\u00advam\u00adpi. Hol\u00admes on nimit\u00adt\u00e4in \u00e4\u00e4rim\u00adm\u00e4i\u00adsen ep\u00e4\u00adso\u00adsi\u00adaa\u00adli\u00adnen, ja sar\u00adja antaa ymm\u00e4r\u00adt\u00e4\u00e4, ett\u00e4 h\u00e4nen kiin\u00adnos\u00adtuk\u00adsen\u00adsa ihmi\u00adsiin rajoit\u00adtuu yksi\u00adno\u00admaan nii\u00adhin fak\u00adtoi\u00adhin, joi\u00adta h\u00e4n heis\u00adt\u00e4 kyke\u00adnee irti puris\u00adta\u00admaan. N\u00e4in Hol\u00adme\u00adsin p\u00e4\u00e4t\u00adte\u00adly\u00adket\u00adjut aina\u00adkin peri\u00adaat\u00adtees\u00adsa nojaa\u00advat enem\u00adm\u00e4n tapah\u00adtu\u00adnei\u00adsiin asioi\u00adhin ja kon\u00adkreet\u00adti\u00adsiin todis\u00adtei\u00adsiin (jalan\u00adj\u00e4l\u00adjet, vaa\u00adte\u00adkui\u00addut, tupa\u00adkan\u00adtuh\u00adka ja niin edel\u00adleen) kuin Poi\u00adrot\u2019n, joka v\u00e4sy\u00adm\u00e4t\u00adt\u00e4 koros\u00adtaa ihmis\u00adten ja psy\u00adko\u00adlo\u00adgian mer\u00adki\u00adtys\u00adt\u00e4, ja jos jos\u00adkus ereh\u00adtyy\u00adkin sot\u00adke\u00admaan k\u00e4ten\u00ads\u00e4 ty\u00f6s\u00ads\u00e4\u00e4n, se tapah\u00adtuu vain sen takia, ett\u00e4 h\u00e4n on saa\u00adnut ihmi\u00adsi\u00e4 haas\u00adta\u00adtel\u00adtu\u00adaan esiin jotain, johon perus\u00adtu\u00advat p\u00e4\u00e4\u00adtel\u00adm\u00e4t t\u00e4m\u00e4n kon\u00adkreet\u00adti\u00adsen ty\u00f6n tulok\u00adse\u00adna esiin tule\u00advat todis\u00adteet sit\u00adten vain lopul\u00adli\u00adses\u00adti sine\u00adt\u00f6i\u00adv\u00e4t. #<\/a><\/p>\n

Esi\u00admer\u00adkik\u00adsi eili\u00adses\u00ads\u00e4 \u201cKoh\u00adta\u00adlo\u00adkas vii\u00adkon\u00adlop\u00adpu\u201d -jak\u00adsos\u00adsa (The Hol\u00adlow<\/a>) Poi\u00adrot kai\u00advoi savi\u00adveis\u00adtok\u00adseen k\u00e4t\u00adke\u00adtyn aseen esil\u00adle omin k\u00e4sin, mut\u00adta vas\u00adta las\u00adket\u00adtu\u00adaan yhteen sen, ett\u00e4 k\u00e4t\u00adken\u00adn\u00e4n teh\u00adnyt tai\u00adtei\u00adli\u00adja oli sano\u00adnut inhoa\u00advan\u00adsa hevo\u00adsia, ja sen, ett\u00e4 sii\u00adt\u00e4 huo\u00adli\u00admat\u00adta h\u00e4n oli muo\u00adtoil\u00adlut saves\u00adta hevo\u00adsen\u00adp\u00e4\u00e4n. Samal\u00adla t\u00e4m\u00e4 havain\u00adnol\u00adlis\u00adtaa hyvin sit\u00e4 yksioi\u00adkois\u00adta maa\u00adil\u00admaa, jos\u00adsa molem\u00admat klas\u00adsik\u00adkoet\u00adsi\u00adv\u00e4t el\u00e4\u00adv\u00e4t: tai\u00adtei\u00adli\u00adja inho\u00adaa hevo\u00adsia, joten hevo\u00adsen\u00adp\u00e4\u00e4\u00adveis\u00adtok\u00adses\u00adsa on olta\u00adva<\/em> jotain ep\u00e4i\u00adlyt\u00adt\u00e4\u00adv\u00e4\u00e4. Todel\u00adli\u00adses\u00adsa maa\u00adil\u00admas\u00adsa tai\u00adtei\u00adli\u00adjan syyt oli\u00adsi\u00advat toden\u00adn\u00e4\u00adk\u00f6i\u00adses\u00adti olleet jotain aivan muu\u00adta ja Poi\u00adrot oli\u00adsi tuhon\u00adnut veis\u00adtok\u00adsen ihan tur\u00adhaan. #<\/a><\/p>\n

T\u00e4m\u00e4n palik\u00adka\u00adlo\u00adgii\u00adkan kul\u00admi\u00adnoi\u00adtu\u00adma on Hol\u00adme\u00adsin is\u00e4l\u00adt\u00e4\u00e4n peri\u00adm\u00e4 v\u00e4it\u00adt\u00e4\u00adm\u00e4, jon\u00adka mukaan sen j\u00e4l\u00adkeen, kun mah\u00addo\u00adton on eli\u00admi\u00adnoi\u00adtu, totuus on se, mit\u00e4 on j\u00e4\u00e4\u00adnyt j\u00e4l\u00adjel\u00adle, vaik\u00adka se vai\u00adkut\u00adtai\u00adsi kuin\u00adka ep\u00e4todenn\u00e4k\u00f6iselt\u00e4.\u201cWhen you have eli\u00admi\u00adna\u00adted the impos\u00adsible, wha\u00adte\u00adver remains, howe\u00adver impro\u00adbable, must be the truth.\u201d Sovel\u00adlet\u00adtu Wikiquo\u00adten Sher\u00adlock Hol\u00admes -sitaa\u00adteis\u00adta<\/a>. T\u00e4m\u00e4 voi p\u00e4te\u00e4 mate\u00adma\u00adtii\u00adkas\u00adsa, mut\u00adta tosie\u00adl\u00e4\u00adm\u00e4n tapah\u00adtu\u00adma\u00adket\u00adju\u00adjen vaih\u00adtoeh\u00adto\u00adjen \u00e4\u00e4re\u00adt\u00f6n m\u00e4\u00e4\u00adr\u00e4 tekee sii\u00adt\u00e4 t\u00e4y\u00adsin hy\u00f6\u00addyt\u00adt\u00f6\u00adm\u00e4n k\u00e4y\u00adt\u00e4n\u00adn\u00f6n ohje\u00adnuo\u00adra\u00adna. Tosia\u00adsias\u00adsa Hol\u00admes\u00adkaan ei nou\u00adda\u00adta t\u00e4t\u00e4 ohjet\u00adta muu\u00adtoin kuin sil\u00adloin, kun logiik\u00adkaa tar\u00advi\u00adtaan ja se ehdot\u00adto\u00admas\u00adti toi\u00admii. Sen j\u00e4l\u00adkeen Hol\u00admes tekee kuten jokai\u00adnen meis\u00adt\u00e4, eli k\u00e4yt\u00adt\u00e4\u00e4 n\u00e4i\u00adt\u00e4 joh\u00adto\u00adp\u00e4\u00e4\u00adt\u00f6k\u00adsi\u00ad\u00e4\u00e4n pyy\u00addyk\u00adse\u00adn\u00e4, jon\u00adka heit\u00adt\u00e4\u00e4 intui\u00adtion veteen uusia joh\u00adto\u00adp\u00e4\u00e4\u00adt\u00f6k\u00adsi\u00e4 kalas\u00adtaak\u00adseen. Se, ett\u00e4 h\u00e4n jat\u00adku\u00advas\u00adti koros\u00adtaa p\u00e4\u00e4\u00adtel\u00admien\u00ads\u00e4 loo\u00adgi\u00adsuut\u00adta, on jyr\u00adk\u00e4s\u00ads\u00e4 ris\u00adti\u00adrii\u00addas\u00adsa h\u00e4nen toi\u00admin\u00adtan\u00adsa kans\u00adsa, mik\u00e4 ker\u00adtoo joko hah\u00admon tai sen luo\u00adjan kyvyt\u00adt\u00f6\u00admyy\u00addes\u00adt\u00e4 int\u00adros\u00adpek\u00adtioon. #<\/a><\/p>\n

Moder\u00adnis\u00adsa fik\u00adtios\u00adsa on kol\u00admas\u00adkin saman\u00adlai\u00adnen hah\u00admo, joka tosin ei ty\u00f6k\u00adseen jah\u00adtaa rikol\u00adli\u00adsia: Star Tre\u00adkin Spock<\/a> edus\u00adtaa saman\u00adlais\u00adta logii\u00adkan yli\u00adval\u00adtaa ajat\u00adte\u00adlus\u00adsa. Star Tre\u00adkin ansiok\u00adsi voi\u00addaan ehk\u00e4 las\u00adkea se, ett\u00e4 se edes yrit\u00adt\u00e4\u00e4 antaa intui\u00adtii\u00advi\u00adsel\u00adle ajat\u00adte\u00adlul\u00adle pai\u00adkan logii\u00adkan rin\u00adnal\u00adla (ja jopa sen joh\u00adta\u00adja\u00adna eli t\u00e4h\u00adti\u00adlai\u00advan kap\u00adtee\u00adni\u00adna), mut\u00adta vali\u00adtet\u00adta\u00advas\u00adti Kir\u00adkin, McCo\u00adyn ja kump\u00adpa\u00adnei\u00adden ajoit\u00adtai\u00adset \u00e4rsyt\u00adt\u00e4\u00advyy\u00addet ja suo\u00adra\u00adnai\u00adset type\u00adryy\u00addet yhdis\u00adtet\u00adty\u00adn\u00e4 sii\u00adhen, ett\u00e4 Spoc\u00adkin ajat\u00adte\u00adlu on Star Tre\u00adkin maa\u00adil\u00admas\u00adsa yht\u00e4 yli\u00adver\u00adtai\u00adnen nii\u00adhin n\u00e4h\u00adden kuin Hol\u00adme\u00adsin tai Poi\u00adrot\u2019n ajat\u00adte\u00adlu mui\u00adhin aika\u00adlai\u00adsiin\u00adsa ver\u00adrat\u00adtu\u00adna, tekee sil\u00adle l\u00e4hin\u00adn\u00e4 kar\u00adhun\u00adpal\u00adve\u00adluk\u00adsen. #<\/a><\/p>\n

Itse asias\u00adsa Spock\u00adkaan ei ole toi\u00admin\u00adnas\u00adsaan l\u00e4hes\u00adk\u00e4\u00e4n niin loo\u00adgi\u00adnen kuin antaa puheis\u00adsaan ymm\u00e4r\u00adt\u00e4\u00e4, vaik\u00adka\u00adkin h\u00e4nel\u00adl\u00e4 on sii\u00adhen teko\u00adsyy, jol\u00adlai\u00adnen sek\u00e4 Hol\u00adme\u00adsil\u00adta ett\u00e4 Poi\u00adrot\u2019l\u00adta puut\u00adtuu: Spoc\u00adkin kyl\u00adm\u00e4 j\u00e4r\u00adki\u00adpuo\u00adli tulee toi\u00adsel\u00adta pla\u00adnee\u00adtal\u00adta, ja emo\u00adtio\u00adnaa\u00adli\u00adnen puo\u00adli, joka selit\u00adt\u00e4\u00e4 h\u00e4nen toi\u00admin\u00adta- ja jous\u00adto\u00adky\u00adky\u00ad\u00e4\u00e4n on inhi\u00admil\u00adli\u00adsen peri\u00adm\u00e4n \u201cheik\u00adkout\u00adta\u201d. #<\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"

Muis\u00adtan, kuin\u00adka pie\u00adne\u00adn\u00e4 pidin Poi\u00adrot\u2019s\u00adta pal\u00adjon enem\u00adm\u00e4n kuin Hol\u00adme\u00adsis\u00adta. Itse asias\u00adsa minua har\u00admit\u00adti se, etten tyk\u00e4n\u00adnyt Hol\u00ad\u00admes-sar\u00ad\u00adjas\u00ad\u00adta, kos\u00adka tie\u00adsin kui\u00adten\u00adkin, ett\u00e4 Hol\u00adme\u00adsia pidet\u00adtiin yhte\u00adn\u00e4 klas\u00adsik\u00adkoet\u00adsi\u00advis\u00adt\u00e4 (jol\u00adlei per\u00e4\u00adti klas\u00adsi\u00adsim\u00adpa\u00adna) Poi\u00adrot\u2019n ohel\u00adla. # Se, etten tyk\u00e4n\u00adnyt Hol\u00adme\u00adsis\u00adta, joh\u00adtui ennen muu\u00adta sii\u00adt\u00e4, ett\u00e4 koin, ett\u00e4 sar\u00adjas\u00adsa pimi\u00adtet\u00adtiin kat\u00adso\u00adjal\u00adta arvoi\u00adtus\u00adten rat\u00adkai\u00adse\u00admi\u00adsen kan\u00adnal\u00adta kes\u00adkei\u00adsi\u00e4 joh\u00adto\u00adlan\u00adko\u00adja; Hol\u00admes saat\u00adtoi yht\u00e4k\u00adki\u00e4 ker\u00adtoa jos\u00adtain p\u00e4\u00e4telm\u00e4st\u00e4\u00e4n [\u2026]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"wp_typography_post_enhancements_disabled":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[11444],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-1458","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-merkinnat"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/mummila.net\/marginaali\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1458","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/mummila.net\/marginaali\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/mummila.net\/marginaali\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/mummila.net\/marginaali\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/mummila.net\/marginaali\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=1458"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/mummila.net\/marginaali\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1458\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/mummila.net\/marginaali\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=1458"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/mummila.net\/marginaali\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=1458"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/mummila.net\/marginaali\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=1458"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}